Educators Grapple with AI’s Impact on Student Learning and Academic Integrity

The rapid integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into education is reshaping how students learn and complete assignments, sparking debate among educators about its impact on academic integrity and critical thinking. While AI-powered tools offer new opportunities for personalized learning, they also present significant challenges, particularly in detecting AI-generated work and ensuring students genuinely engage with the learning process.

Educators across the country are seeing a rise in students using AI to complete assignments, often without fully understanding the material. Jessica, a high school teacher from Pennsylvania, has seen students rely on AI to produce assignments rather than develop their own skills.

“I have not yet seen students use AI to enhance their education,” she said. “I know a lot who’ve used the technology only to acquire answers.”

Unlike traditional plagiarism, AI-generated content is not copied from another source but is still not the student’s own work. This creates difficulties for teachers trying to assess genuine learning. Michelle, an English teacher in the Northeast, has developed creative strategies to catch AI-generated assignments.

“A ‘Trojan Horse’ I use to identify AI-written work is to sneak a bizarre tidbit into their instructions,” she said. “When they mention JIF peanut butter or the Millennium Falcon in their essay on Romeo & Juliet, they’re busted!”

Beyond the issue of cheating, AI is raising broader concerns about the development of critical thinking and writing skills. Some educators worry that students relying too heavily on AI will struggle to develop their own analytical abilities. Others are concerned that AI will widen existing educational disparities, benefiting students who use it effectively while leaving others behind.

Despite these challenges, some teachers see AI as a tool that, when used responsibly, could help students improve their learning. With the right guidance, AI could be integrated into classrooms to enhance research, provide personalized tutoring, and support students with different learning styles. However, educators say that clear guidelines are needed to ensure AI is used as a supplement to learning rather than a replacement for it.”We need to redefine what learning looks like in an AI-driven world,” Michelle said. “Instead of banning it outright, we should be teaching students how to use AI ethically and critically—just as we did when the internet first became widely accessible.”

As schools continue to navigate the role of AI in education, educators are calling for updated policies, professional development, and classroom strategies that address both the risks and opportunities of this rapidly evolving technology.

For more insights on how AI is shaping student learning, visit My Pay My Say.

About My Pay My Say

My Pay My Say (MPMS) is dedicated to empowering educators by providing critical resources, advocacy, and support to navigate challenges in today’s classrooms. MPMS promotes policies that prioritize teacher autonomy, student success, and access to the tools necessary for a high-quality education. Through research, outreach, and actionable solutions, MPMS helps educators make informed decisions and create positive learning environments. Learn more at mypaymysay.com.